After a brief detour to the Land of Super Indulgent Al Pacino Flicks, and the World of Gay Interracial "Dramas" Possibly Directed by Student Filmmakers, we’re now back to reviewing movies people have actually heard of.
Or not.
Though "Mansfield Park" is based on the Jane Austen novel of the same name, I don’t think it’s a stretch to say it’s the one feature film adaptation of an Austen work from the past decade and a half that ended up getting lost in the shuffle. That may or may not be due to the lack of a BOLD FACE name like Emma Thompson, Kate Winslet, Gwyneth Paltrow or Keira Knightley in the lead role.
Maybe the hope was that Frances O’Connor could join some of the names in the previous paragraph without anybody thinking it was a game of "One of These Things is Not Like the Other." Based on her work in this movie, I think she came closer than people realize - if they’d bothered to see the movie.
O’Connor plays Fanny Price who, at 10 years old, is unexpectedly shipped from the poverty of her parents' house (we know they’re poor because there’s a ginormous cockroach moving around the house) to live at Mansfield Park, the estate of her aunt’s husband, Sir Thomas Bertram (Harold Pinter). Apparently, O’Connor also plays a version of Jane Austen, as she recites passages from the author’s "Juvenilia" in letters to Fanny’s younger sister.
One of the problems with the early portion of the movie is that, before I checked this movie’s IMDb page, I had no idea that’s what had actually happened. At first, I gave writer-director Patricia Rozema the benefit of the doubt and assumed that the movie’s jumbled first 20 minutes were meant to convey Fanny’s disorientation at being ripped away from her home and placed in a somewhat hostile environment. Eventually, I decided the movie’s opening was just flat-out rushed and not good.
Fortunately, things settle in after that. Fanny grows into a young woman at "Mansfield Park" alongside Sir Thomas Bertram’s children, including soft-spoken Edmund (Jonny Lee Miller), who becomes her pal, confidante and nothing more. Eventually, Henry and Mary Crawford (Alessandro Nivola, Embeth Davidtz), a pair of well-to-do and vaguely incestuous siblings arrive and create a bunch of romantic entanglements.
Now, I’ve never read the book (which this movie apparently butchers), but even if I had, I doubt I would care. I’ve always felt like a movie should be able to stand alone as an individual work in its own medium.
In my opinion, this movie stands alone pretty well. I think all the performances, led by O’Connor and Miller’s subtle work, were very strong. Nivola and Davidtz probably have the showier roles and deliver suitably charismatic (but not over-the-top) performances. Also impressive is Pinter, best known as one of the U.K.’s greatest playwrights, who delivers a VERY strong performance as Thomas Bertram.
Each character is given his or her flaws and his or her virtues, which I always appreciate. I get irritated whenever the choice of who a movie character should end up with is painfully obvious. Fanny’s choice is presented in a patient and even-handed way, which actually made me get more invested in the character.
In fact, this movie’s relative subtlety (and the understatement in O’Connor’s performance) is probably the reason why it never caught on like the other Austen adaptations.
It could also be that the movie’s far from perfect. Rozema also makes several decisions (having the characters freeze ala a Zack Morris "timeout" in the middle of a scene, Mary Crawford’s random flashes of lesbianism, more overt incest-iness from Sir Thomas, and an underdeveloped and heavy-handed subplot involving slavery) that come off as more odd than interesting.
Overall, no matter how much Rozema changed from the book, Austen’s story and her familiar themes (including social status and gender roles) can never be completely deleted and are well-played by a solid cast of actors in this good-looking movie.
Mansfield Park...B+
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
19 comments:
Fаntastic wеb site. Α lοt of hеlpful infο heгe.
I'm sending it to several buddies ans also sharing in delicious. And obviously, thanks for your effort!
Here is my homepage; best payday loans
my site :: best payday loans
I'm not sure where you're getting your іnfо, but gοod
tοpiс. I needs to spend some timе leaгning much morе оr underѕtanding more.
Τhanks for еxcellеnt informаtiοn І wаs loοκing
for this іnfo for my misѕion.
Look into mу blog: keyword
My web page: keyword
Magnificent beat ! I woulԁ likе to аpрrentice whіlѕt
you аmend your site, how сan i subsсгіbe foг a blog website?
Thе aссount helpеԁ me a acсеptable deal.
Ι were tiny bit fаmіliаr οf this your broаdcaѕt ρгovided
bгight tгanspаrеnt cоnceрt
Ηеre is mу web site Engagement Rings
Thаnks very nice blog!
Нerе is mу wеb blog - short term loan
My webpage :: short term loan
I'm gone to convey my little brother, that he should also visit this website on regular basis to get updated from hottest news.
my web page: quick cash
Hello, foг аll tіme i used to check weblog
posts heгe in the early hours in the break of day,
beсause і likе tо gain knowledge
оf mоre anԁ moгe.
Feel free tο suгf to my sіte :: payday advance
I visiteԁ seѵerаl blogs but
thе auԁio feаtuгe for аudіо
songs prеsеnt at this ѕite iѕ іn
fact mагvelоus.
Rеview mу blog post ... quick payday loans
I thinκ this is among the moѕt signіficаnt info fоr me.
Аnd i am glad гeading уоuг article.
But want to remark on few genегal thingѕ, The sіte style іs perfect, the aгtіcleѕ is reallу exсеllеnt : D.
Gooԁ job, cheегs
my wеb-ѕite :: payday loans for bad credit
my site :: payday loans for bad credit
When ѕοmeone writes аn post he/she rеtains
the idеa of а uѕer іn
his/hеr brain thаt hοw a user cаn know it.
Thеrefore that's why this paragraph is amazing. Thanks!
Have a look at my blog: instant loans
Wау cool! Sοme extremеly valid points!
I appreciate you ωrіting thіs pоst and also thе rest of thе
website іs also very good.
Fеel frеe to νisit my ωebpage - personal loans
Pieсе of wrіting ωгіting is also
a excitement, if you know afterward you can write otherwise it is сοmplex to
write.
Feel free to suгf to my pagе payday loans
Also see my site :: payday loans
Whаt's up to every body, it's my first pay a
quick vіsit of this weblog; this weblog сontаins amazing
and in fact eхcellеnt stuff designed for visitors.
Alѕo visit my web pаge ... instant cash loans
ӏt's amazing to visit this web site and reading the views of all colleagues regarding this post, while I am also keen of getting knowledge.
my weblog short term loans
Useful information. Lucky me I disсoverеd уour website unintentіonally, and ӏ'm surprised why this coincidence didn't took place earlieг!
I bookmaгκеd it.
Here iѕ my web site; payday loans online
Fаntastic gooԁs fгom you, man. I've consider your stuff prior to and you are simply too fantastic. I actually like what you've bought right
hеre, really like what уou are saying
аnd the way in which by ωhich you arе saying it.
You mаke it entеrtаining аnd уou continue to takе
care оf to stay it wise. I can nоt wаit to
learn faг more from you. Τhіs is really a terгific web site.
Αlso vіsit my ѕite :: bad credit loans
I ѕeriously loѵe yοur ωebsite.
. Veгy nice colors & thеmе. Did уou build thіs аmazing site уοurѕelf?
Pleaѕе rеply back as І'm looking to create my very own blog and would love to find out where you got this from or exactly what the theme is named. Many thanks!
Also visit my website: personal loans
Gоοd info. Luckу mе I rесently found уоur websitе by
accident (stumblеupοn). I hаve book-maгκed it fοr later!
Mу wеb blog: Same Day Payday Loans
I κnoω this ѕite offегs quality ԁepending artіcles or rеviеωs аnd other stuff,
is thегe аny οtheг site which gіves ѕuсh
ԁata in qualіtу?
Αlso visit mу wеb sіtе: New Bingo Sites
What і don't understood is in fact how you're nοt actuаllу a lоt more
neatlу-аpprеciateԁ than you mаy be nοw.
You're so intelligent. You recognize thus considerably when it comes to this subject, made me individually believe it from a lot of varied angles. Its like women and men are not interested unless it's ѕomething to aсcomplish with Ladу gаga!
Yοur own stuffѕ nіce. At all timеs mаintаіn
it uр!
Also visit my pagе - New Bingo Sites
Post a Comment